"Looks like she’s smiling." Detective Rick Patterson
snapped another picture.
"Have a heart," I said, "she’s somebody’s daughter."
I jumped from the boat and sank to my knees in the
marsh. Muddy water seeped into my shoes and a swarm of
mosquitoes rose up from the marsh grass to greet me. I
fought my way through the slush to where the grass grew
in thicker clumps and followed them until I reached the
edge of the gully where Rick stood. Sweat poured off me
from the heat of the August sun. I was no stranger to
the Southern Louisiana heat, but it was an unusually hot
summer. It felt as though Hell’s doors had been opened.
"How long do you think she’s been here?" Rick asked.
I rolled up my sleeves and stared at the swollen
body. She lay on her back in a shallow gully. The seams
on her blue shorts and red T-shirt stretched to the
point of ripping, the bones in her hands and face were
exposed, and the smell … gut wrenching.
"I don’t know," I said. I held my breath and tried to
get close to the body.
"Who found her?"
"A fisherman," Rick said. He pointed to where the
gully merged with Bayou Lafourche. "My guess is she
floated in through there when the tide was high and when
the tide went out she was stranded. No sign of trauma.
Looks like she drowned, then floated down the bayou
until she got here."
The Water Patrol sergeant stumbled toward us dragging
two long planks. I helped him drop them across the
gully, one on each side of the body. I inched across the
planks for a closer look. The woman’s hair was black.
Her gray eyes bulged. The flesh around her mouth was
gone, exposing a row of bright white teeth. Rick was
right; it looked like she was smiling. "Any missing
persons reports?" I asked.
"Yeah. Some guy, Joey Coleman, reported his wife
missing a few days ago."
"She match the description?"
Rick nodded. "Down to her decomposed face."
I shot him a hard look. He smiled his apology.
"Really," he said. He slapped a mosquito that drank
from his neck. "She matches the physical description.
Even wearing the clothes her husband described."
"Name?"
"Cynthia."
I tilted the woman’s head and noticed a gold, loop
earring in her right ear. The left one was missing. I
moved to her feet and noticed her left foot was bare. A
white sneaker that displayed a Nike emblem was on her
right foot.
I looked up and down the bayou. There was nothing
north of us for miles. To the South, the Leeville Bridge
and a smattering of fishing camps. "How’d she get in the
water?" I asked.
"Fell off a boat. Jumped off the bridge. Take your
pick."
When we were done at the scene, we loaded her body
into the boat. The hearse waited at Guidry’s Boat
Landing.
It was still early morning when Rick and I found Joey
Coleman at his house in Galliano, a small town thirty
miles north of Leeville. He looked to be in his thirties
and his callused hands told me he was a laborer. I
showed him my badge. "Hi, I’m Detective Brandon Wolfe
and this is my partner, Detective Rick Patterson. We
need to speak with you concerning the missing persons
report you filed—"
"Oh God, she’s dead!" His blue eyes widened. He
turned to his table and sank into a chair.
"We don’t know for sure," I said, moving closer. "We
need you to come to the morgue and look at the body."
He squeezed his eyes shut and hung his head. He cried
out loud. I shifted my feet and looked at Rick. He
rolled his eyes. I shook my head—he needed a lesson in
compassion. When Joey looked up, his face was red and
streaked with tears. He nodded and said in a quiet
voice, "I’m ready."
Rick and I drove Joey to the morgue and Doctor Rachel
Looper led us into the cold autopsy room. Before we
entered I turned to Joey. "Prepare yourself. She’s been
exposed to the elements."
The woman’s body was on its back on the stainless
steel table. Her appearance was shocking and the room
reeked of decayed flesh. Joey didn’t seem to notice. He
rushed to the body and threw himself against it. He
shook violently and uttered something that I couldn’t
make out. After several minutes, I put my hand on his
shoulder and guided him out of the room.
He nodded. "She’s wearing the same clothes she left
for work in." He pulled a cigarette from his pocket and
lit it. His hands trembled.
"When was that?"
"What?"
"When did she leave for work?"
"Friday morning. About six o’clock."
"Where’d she work?"
"Southside Restaurant. She was a waitress."
"That the last time you saw her?"
"Yeah." He sank to the curb and lowered his head to
his knees.
I squatted beside him. "Have y’all been having
problems?"
"We argued sometimes. Nothing serious."
"What was she doing in Leeville?"
Joey threw his hands in the air. "That’s the crazy
thing. We never go to Leeville. We don’t even know
anyone there. Unless…."
"Unless what?"
He shook his head. "No, no. Cynthia would never do
anything like that."
"How can you be sure?"
Tears streamed down Joey’s face. "Because she loved
me. You don’t do that to someone you love."
I called for a patrol cruiser to take Joey home.
"I’ll need the names of her doctors, dentists, stuff
like that." I said. "I need a statement from you, too.
Tomorrow maybe. Meanwhile, try to get some rest."
Joey nodded and didn’t say another word until the
cruiser arrived. Before he got inside, he grabbed my arm
and stared into my eyes. "Find out who did this to my
wife!"
When we returned to the autopsy room, Doctor Looper
was busy on Cynthia Coleman’s body. She looked up and
pulled the mask from her face. Her freckled nose and
porcelain complexion made an attractive combination.
"Didn’t y’all say her body was found in the bayou?"
I nodded.
"This woman drowned, but not in the bayou. There’s no
soot or mud in her throat or lungs. Clean water killed
her. My guess is a swimming pool."
"There’s not a swimming pool within ten miles of
Leeville," I said.
"She was dumped," Rick said.
"No signs of trauma?" I asked.
"None that I can tell." Looper peeled off her gloves.
"I think she was moved after she died. Now you have to
find out why."
Rick and I drove to Southside Restaurant and spoke
with Cynthia’s manager, Daisy O’Conner. Daisy’s blood
shot eyes and swollen cheeks were a dead giveaway that
she already knew about Cynthia’s death. She served us
steaming coffee and settled down behind the counter.
"Cynthia was a sweetheart," she said. "Always happy.
I’ll miss her for sure."
"She have problems with anyone?" I asked.
"No, everybody loved her."
"How about her husband?" Rick asked.
"He called a lot. I heard her arguing with him a few
times."
"About what?"
"Well, he came here once when she was talking to a
male customer. She was just being friendly, but he got
mad. She left work early that day."
"The jealous type?" Rick asked.
"She never really said, but it seems so."
"Did he have reason?" I asked.
"What do you mean?"
"Was she fooling around?"
Daisy shifted in her seat. "I don’t know, like, for a
fact, but I think there was somebody."
"Who?"
"He’s a regular. Comes in about three times a
week—evenings mostly. Cynthia always waited on him. She
spent a lot of time at his table. He would wait outside
for her sometimes. I saw them leave together once."
"Did she ever say anything about him?"
"Never. And I never asked."
"What’s his name?" Rick asked.
Daisy smiled and shook her head. "Funny thing, I
never heard his name mentioned."
"When was the last time he was here?" Rick asked.
"Wednesday, I think."
"Was Cynthia working that night?"
"Yeah."
"Was that the last time you saw her?" I asked.
"No," Daisy said. "The last time I saw her was
Thursday night when she left. She was supposed to work
Friday evening, but she never showed."
I looked at Rick and he nodded. He and I had been
partners too long—we could read each other’s mind. I
leaned closer to Daisy and stared into her dark brown
eyes. "We’re gonna need your help," I said.
"Anything," she said. The corners of her mouth
twitched and her eyes glowed.
I pointed to a table in the corner of the dining
area. "We’re gonna wait there. If our guy walks in, I
want you to point him out to us. We’ll take care of the
rest. Got it?"
She started to nod and her face suddenly fell. "I
thought Cynthia drowned? You don’t think—"
I shook my head. "This is routine. Nothing to worry
about." She didn’t look convinced.
We waited a couple of hours and were about to order
dinner when a tall, thin man strode into the restaurant.
His dress slacks and sports coat seemed out of place
beneath his dark and weather-beaten face. He took his
seat in one of the booths and my eyes found Daisy. She
had just emerged from the kitchen. She froze in place
and looked in our direction. When our eyes locked, she
nodded and hurried back into the kitchen.
"That’s him," I told Rick. We made our way to his
booth. I showed him my badge. "What’s your name?" I
asked.
"Andrew Rowdy. Why?"
"We need to ask you some questions down at our
office," I said.
Andrew looked surprised. "What about?"
"We’ll discuss that when we get there," Rick said.
"You just come along so we can get this done with. Then
you can get back to your business."
"Well, okay, but I’d still like to know what this is
about."
I pointed to the door. "You’ll know soon enough."
When we were seated in the interview room, I offered
Andrew a cigarette. He took it.
"Tell me about your relationship with Cynthia
Coleman," I said.
His brow furrowed. "Who?"
I propped my elbows on the desk and leaned close to
him. "Don’t play stupid. You know who."
Andrew licked his lips and shifted in his chair. "I
don’t know anyone by that name." He fumbled in his
pocket for a lighter.
"Andy, you’re fixing to cause yourself a world of
grief. Tell me about your relationship with—"
"I don’t know who you’re talking about. And if I did,
what business is it of yours?"
Rick jerked a Polaroid of Cynthia Coleman’s
body from his pocket. I winced when he threw it on the
desk. Andrew recoiled in horror. His cigarette spat from
his mouth and fell to the floor.
"It became our business when we pulled her out the
bayou." Rick’s voice was loud. "If this doesn’t refresh
your memory, a punch in the head will!"
I put my hand on Rick’s outstretched arm. He jerked
it from me and stormed out the room.
Andrew’s face was ashen. "Is that really her?"
I nodded. He buried his face in his hands and it was
then that I noticed the gold band around his ring
finger. I collected his cigarette from the floor. He
stuffed it in his mouth and I held the lighter for him.
He nodded his thanks. A couple of drags later he was
calm.
"Want to tell me about your relationship with
Cynthia?"
"I’m married with three kids. If my wife finds out
about this..."
"She won’t." I slid the ashtray to him. "When did you
last see Cynthia?"
He let out a long sigh. "Friday afternoon."
"Did you meet her somewhere?"
He shook his head. "She came to my camp. We were
there—"
"Your camp? Where is it?"
"La 1. Leeville."
"Where in Leeville?"
"Just before the bridge. Why?"
I leaned across the desk. "Because Cynthia’s body was
found in the bayou just north of the Leeville Bridge.
Ain’t that a hell of a coincidence?"
Andrew’s mouth dropped. "Are you saying I did this?"
I shrugged. "What time did Cynthia leave your camp?"
Andrew’s eyes were desperate. "Uh, about 2:30 PM.
Look, I swear I didn’t have anything to do with—"
"Do you own a swimming pool?"
"What’s that got to do with this?"
"Is that a yes or no?"
"I don’t have one."
"Has Cynthia ever been to your house?"
"Never. My wife stays home with our youngest."
"Do you mind if we search your camp and your car?"
Andrew hesitated. "Maybe I need to call a lawyer."
I stood up to walk out the room. Andrew reached out
with his hand. "Wait," he said. "Where’re you going?"
"Oh, you suddenly want to talk again." I sat down.
"Listen, did you have anything to do with Cynthia’s
death?"
"No, I didn’t."
"Then you shouldn’t have a problem with us searching
your camp. Am I right?"
Andrew thought for awhile, then nodded. "I just don’t
want my wife knowing what’s up."
We arrived at Andrew Rowdy’s camp just after dark. It
was a yellow, wooden cabin built high off the ground. It
was only about a mile from where Cynthia Coleman’s body
was discovered. A search of the interior yielded
nothing. We moved outside and I walked toward the wharf.
Andrew was on my heels. Rick wandered off through the
tall marsh grass. His flashlight swept from left to
right as he trudged along.
"What are y’all looking for?" Andrew asked when we
reached the water’s edge.
"We’ll know when we find it." The moonlight was
bright over the water and the marsh grass danced in the
wind like a music-box monkey. The steady breeze kept the
mosquitoes away—much to our relief. It all made for a
pleasant night. I almost forgot my reason for being
there, when Rick called out. He stared down at something
in the marsh about a hundred yards north of Andrew’s
camp. When I reached his side, he pointed to a shoe in
the mud—a woman’s white Nike sneaker.
Andrew looked over my shoulder. "What’s that?"
"Wait for us by your camp," Rick said. When Andrew
did as ordered, Rick continued. "See these drag marks
and foot impressions? They start by the road and go to
the water’s edge."
"She was dumped here." I looked at Andrew. He sat on
the steps to his camp. "You think he did it?"
Rick shrugged. "If you killed her, would you dump her
in your back yard?"
"You have a point. Let’s call it a night and talk to
Joey tomorrow. He might be able to shed a little light
on this case."
I met Rick at the squad room early the next morning.
He handed me a phone message. "This mail carrier said
she wants to talk to the detectives working Cynthia
Coleman’s death."
We found the mail carrier at the Post Office loading
her shoulder bag. Her blonde hair was drenched. She
sighed when we walked up. "I can’t wait until winter."
"I understand you might have some information for
us," I began.
"It might be nothing." She sat on one of the nearby
crates. "I was making my rounds on East 7th Street,
Friday. When I put the mail in Mr. and Mrs. Coleman’s
box, I could hear them arguing inside. Sounded pretty
intense."
"What time?"
"About 3, maybe later."
I rubbed my head. "Are you sure it was Mr. and Mrs.
Coleman?"
"I’m assuming it was. I don’t know their voices well
enough to say I recognized them, but I figured it was
them."
"Did you see them?" Rick asked.
She shook her head. "I didn’t even look at the house.
I felt like I was eavesdropping."
"What were they saying?" I asked.
"I couldn’t make out their words."
Rick and I drove straight to Joey Coleman’s house. He
invited us into the kitchen. I glanced around the room.
Nothing out of place.
"Can I use your bathroom?" I asked.
"Sure." He pointed down a narrow hallway. Once
inside, I locked the door. I searched the drawers and
the closet, but didn’t find any answers. When I knew I’d
been in there too long, I flushed the toilet and turned
toward the door. I stopped. Something shiny caught my
eye. It was swishing around the toilet bowl and got
sucked in with the current. I thought it was gone, but
when the water settled I caught a glimpse of it just
inside the mouth of the toilet … just out of reach. I
jerked a hanger from the closet. I worked it straight
and made a hook on one end. I eased it into the toilet
bowl and dragged the bottom until the shiny object came
into view. When I saw it, my heart stopped. I pulled it
out of the water and washed it in the sink, then dropped
it in my pocket.
I rejoined Rick and Joey. I sat at the table. "Andy,
go over what happened the day your wife disappeared."
A long frown tugged at his mouth and he lowered his
head. "Cynthia had to work that day. I stayed home sick.
I woke up around 12 and checked the mail. I noticed her
car in the driveway. I checked around the house, but I
couldn’t find her. I figured she came home and then left
again with a friend. I felt sick. I went back to sleep.
I must’ve slept forever, because when I woke up it was
dark. She still wasn’t home." Joey stopped and shook his
head. "I started to worry. I called 911 and made a
report. I thought she ran off to her parents in
Mississippi, but they said they hadn’t seen her."
"Has she ever done that before?" Rick asked.
"About a year ago we had some problems and she drove
up there. She stayed there a couple days. I had called
her parents back then, but they said they hadn’t seen
her. I found out later that they lied."
I put my notebook down and stared at Joey. "When’s
the last time you went to Leeville?"
Joey’s face tensed just a little and he blinked
several times. "Uh, it’s been a while. A month or two, I
guess."
I puckered my brows and tilted my head sideways. "You
sure?"
Joey looked at Rick and then back at me. He hesitated
and then nodded slowly.
"What did you and Cynthia argue about Friday?"
"Argue? We didn’t argue."
"Well, what did y’all talk about?"
"We didn’t talk. I didn’t even see her. When I woke
up she was gone."
"You didn’t talk to her before she left for work?"
Joey shook his head. "I, I was sleeping."
I leaned across the table. "If you were sleeping, how
the hell did you know what she was wearing?"
Joey stammered.
I decided to gamble a little. "Is that your welding
truck in the driveway?"
He nodded.
"What would you say if I told you someone saw you in
Leeville within the last couple days?"
Joey’s face fell and his tan faded.
"Have you ever tried to flush a penny down the
toilet?" I asked.
Unable to speak, Joey just shook his head.
"You can’t do it. For some reason, the damn thing
just won’t go down." I pulled the shiny object from my
pocket and tossed it on the table.
Joey’s chin began to tremble when he saw the earring
and one of his legs shook uncontrollably. I moved around
the table and put my hand on his shoulder. "It’s all
right," I said in a quiet voice. "We understand how you
feel. I know you loved Cynthia—I can tell that by
looking around this house. You gave her everything, and
you took such good care of her, but that wasn’t enough,
was it? She just couldn’t be pleased. You were so good
to her and she betrayed you. You couldn’t understand why
she would do that—how she could do it. You were
confused. You didn’t mean to hurt her, you only wanted
answers. Sure, you were upset … you loved her! Love,
Joey, love made you do it. You did it for—"
"Oh, my God!" Joey began crying like a newborn. He
slammed his head onto the table. "I’m so sorry, baby!
I’m so sorry!"
I waited until his crying subsided somewhat and said,
"Tell us what happened. Help us understand exactly how
you feel."
Joey lifted his head. He looked pitiful. "She was
cheating on me," he whispered. "I, I followed her to
that, to that camp. She thought I was working. I’ve been
knowing something was up."
"Did you confront her?" I asked.
"Not at the camp. I parked across the street and
waited until she left. She never saw me. I followed her
home. I waited a few minutes before going inside. I
wanted to calm down. I thought I was calm, but…."
"Go on," I said in a soothing voice.
"I found her in the bathroom. She was still dressed,
but she was running water for a bath. She freaked out
when she saw me. That look on her face … she knew she
was busted!" He wiped his nose on his sleeve. "I don’t
know what happened after that. I just snapped. I
remember holding her head under the water. It felt like
a dream. She struggled some. She tried to push my hands
off her head, but I was too strong. Then she stopped
moving and I realized what I had done. I got scared."
"What did you do then?" I asked.
"I waited until dark. Put Cynthia in the back of my
truck. I drove to Leeville. I threw her in the bayou
next to that guy’s camp. I wanted the cops—y’all—to
think he did it."
"What’s with the earring?" Rick asked.
Joey sighed. "I found it on the floor in the bathroom
just after I called 911. I knew the deputy would be here
any minute, so I threw it in the toilet and flushed it.
I thought it went down, but…."
Joey didn’t say a word on the ride to the parish
jail. When we dropped him off he turned away from the
deputy who was rolling his fingerprints. "Detective."
I stopped and looked into his mournful eyes.
"I really meant what I said out there by the patrol
car."
I tilted my head and tried to think back.
"About you finding out who did that to my wife," he
said. "I wanted to tell you. I just didn’t have the
courage. Thanks for helping me get it off my chest. I
would’ve died otherwise."
I just nodded and glanced at Rick, who said, "That
would’ve been a good—"
"Partner," I said. "Ready for lunch?"
Rick glared at Joey Coleman for what seemed like
forever. He finally shook his head and stormed out of
the room. I followed him to the parking lot. He shook
his fist in the air.
"I’d like ten minutes alone with him."
"It’s not his fault," I said, trying to stifle a
smile. "Love made him do it."
Rick was livid. "Love don’t kill!"